Not one of 99 major federally funded US public transport systems scored highly across every accessibility measure in a new University of Michigan study. The researchers assessed systems serving 85 cities, finding barriers even among the strongest performers. For disabled riders, those barriers can mean being shut out of work, healthcare and social life by services supposedly provided for the public.
The researchers’ Public Transit Accessibility Dashboard examines four areas: whether transport is nearby and reaches enough destinations; whether services run frequently enough to meet demand; affordability, measured through average fare revenue per trip; and riders’ comfort with the provider. It considers the journey from finding information on a website through to reaching a destination, rather than treating access as a matter of fitting a ramp and declaring the job done.
“For a rider with a disability, one barrier can make the entire trip impossible,” said Erica Twardzik, assistant professor at the University of Michigan School of Kinesiology and lead author of the study.
“That is why we designed the dashboard to look across multiple parts of the rider’s experience, not just one feature like ramps or elevators. None of the transit systems we evaluated rated high on all measures of accessibility. This affects ridership and access for the disability community.”
Washington, D.C., Phoenix and San Diego performed best overall. Hampton, Virginia, Allentown, Pennsylvania, and Anchorage, Alaska, performed worst. The researchers emphasised the weakest part of the travel experience when assessing overall accessibility: strong performance in several areas doesn’t necessarily compensate for a barrier that prevents someone completing the journey.
Working-class disabled people on low incomes often can’t afford extra assistance or alternative transport when public services fail. Riders with money to spare have more options. Someone without those resources may have to abandon a journey altogether. A service that exists on a timetable can still be beyond reach, with consequences that extend from lost opportunities to earn a living to missed appointments and isolation.
Nor does an inaccessible service spare society the cost of meeting people’s needs. Where relatives or friends step in to provide transport, they spend their own time and money covering gaps in public provision. Where nobody can help, disabled people bear the consequences themselves. When authorities contain their budgets by leaving needs unmet, they push costs and work into households, where much of that work goes unpaid.
All the systems examined receive federal funding. Public funding alone plainly hasn’t secured dependable access across the measures studied. Under a capitalist state, officials can support services that businesses need while treating provision for people’s wider lives as expenditure to contain. Disabled riders confront those priorities through decisions about routes, timetables, fares and facilities, even when the provider is a public body.
The researchers developed the dashboard with disabled riders, community advocates and other contributors, whose feedback shaped its design. Users can compare cities, examine maps and download data. Previously, accessibility information had been sparse, scattered and rarely presented in plain language. Riders and organisers can use the combined data to challenge authorities, including when favorable overall rankings conceal a serious barrier.
Employers need workers to reach their workplaces, but disabled people’s lives extend far beyond whatever labor a business can profitably employ. Transport serves human needs that can’t be measured by earnings or fare revenue, including care, friendship, education and pleasure. Disabled people don’t owe an employer a profitable day’s work before they’re entitled to leave the house.
