UK and EU Unions Beg for Scraps From Bosses’ Table

The TUC and the ETUC — Britain’s and Europe’s trade union confederations — met with EU and UK ministers in Brussels this week and asked them, politely, to make their trade deals “put jobs and living standards first.” That’s the sum of it. After the EU-UK Summit, union leaders sat down with European Commission Executive Vice President Roxana Minzatu, UK Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds, and First Secretary of State Louise Haigh to plead for a reset that “works for working people.”

Here’s what they want: where businesses save money from less paperwork and fewer trade barriers, those savings should go to workers as better jobs and lower shop prices. They also want future sectoral deals — chemicals and pharmaceuticals, for example — to be built on common high labour standards and “good quality jobs.” And they want Britain included in Made in Europe, the EU’s procurement rulebook that steers public contracts to European companies, so British firms can win those contracts. Plus “specific protections” to help renationalise UK public services, meaning taking services like railways or utilities back into state ownership.

TUC General Secretary Paul Nowak said: “No one thinks the Conservative’s botched Brexit deal is good for Britain – and the UK’s position has been made even worse by Donald Trump’s reckless and unpredictable approach to trade. It’s welcome that the UK and EU have common ground on some key issues that will reduce barriers to trade and protect jobs in manufacturing. It’s now vital any business savings from reduced paperwork are passed on to working people through better jobs and higher living standards. Now the government and the EU need to take the next steps – which includes ensuring we are fully part of Made in Europe. This will be an important way to support good jobs – and must contain specific protections to support renationalisation of UK public services. A better relationship with the EU is a no brainer – it’s time to get a deal that works for workers.”

ETUC General Secretary Esther Lynch added: “The agreements made today between the EU and the UK should have a real impact on the prices people pay at the supermarket, protecting jobs in our vital industries and offering opportunities for young people. At a time of rising global instability, trade unions support these type of common-sense solutions to improving people’s lives that can help protect and create good jobs as well as bringing down the cost-of-living.

“The commitment to international law should not go unnoticed and we fully back the EU-UK’s unwaivering support for the International Criminal Court. Trade unions are calling for an upgrade to workers’ rights commitments so both sides continue to drive up the quality of jobs. This is crucial to improving the competitiveness of our economies at a time when they are being affected by labour and skills shortages caused by bad jobs.”

Now, let’s be clear about what’s happening here. The TUC and ETUC leadership practice what they call “social partnership” — the idea that workers and shareholders share common interests and should sit down together to solve problems. That’s a dead end. Business owners don’t pass on savings out of kindness. They pocket them. When paperwork costs drop, the boss’s profit margin rises. They don’t hand the difference to the workforce unless workers organise and force them to.

The union leaders ask ministers and EU commissioners to make it happen, but those ministers and commissioners serve the same capitalist class that owns the businesses. The EU is an imperialist bloc — a club of powerful capitalist states that carve up markets and protect monopoly profits. Britain, fresh from its botched Brexit deal, is a junior partner begging for access. Trump’s “reckless” trade war is just another round of inter-imperialist rivalry, with workers on both sides paying the price.

The call for renationalisation protections is interesting. Taking public services back into state ownership can be a good thing for workers, especially if the working class controls that state. But the TUC and ETUC aren’t calling for workers’ control. They’re asking the same ministers who cut public spending to protect renationalisation. Don’t hold your breath.

Lynch says the deals should bring down supermarket prices. Maybe. But the bosses who save on paperwork won’t lower prices unless competition forces them to.

Nowak says a better relationship with the EU is a “no brainer.” For whom? British manufacturers want access to EU markets. EU bosses want access to British labour and consumers. Neither side gives a damn about living standards unless workers make them.

The union leaders’ strategy is class collaboration dressed up as common sense. They ask the ruling class to behave nicely. They get a summit, a photo op, and a promise to “consider” things. Meanwhile, workers in Britain and across Europe face the same bosses, the same austerity, the same attacks on jobs and wages. The only way to win better jobs and lower prices is for workers to organise independently of the bosses and their political representatives; to fight for control over production and distribution, not to beg for scraps from the table.

Share post

The Team