Google Showed Deceptive Software Ads More Than 100 Million Times in Europe

Google took down an advert that directed people to a website linked to a known distributor of malicious software. It left 41 others pointing to the same address. Researchers at New York University’s Tandon School of Engineering and Radboud University in the Netherlands found thousands of deceptive software ads in Google’s public archive. Google had shown them more than 100 million times across European markets.

One advertiser promised to reveal anyone’s location from their phone number alone. Google ran the advert for more than two years and displayed it 14.5 million times. The software could have failed to locate a single phone and Google would still have delivered what its own customer had bought. The advertiser was paying Google to find an audience.

Of the nearly 189,000 versions of software adverts the researchers examined, 3,346 made false or unrealistic promises, including offers to recover photographs deleted years ago. Google showed ads in this group nearly 90 million times. When the researchers checked 147 apps promoted through deceptive adverts, they found that Google was still advertising 34 of them after they’d disappeared from app stores. It makes money either way.

Other advertisers tried to frighten people into clicking. The researchers counted 238 ads that falsely warned people their devices had been hacked or infected. Google displayed those warnings more than 16 million times. Another 258 ads concealed who was advertising or what they were promoting, sometimes behind a button marked “Continue”. A person trying to get to the next page could click an advert before they even realised anyone was trying to sell them something. The researchers couldn’t establish how many people lost money or installed harmful software.

“These ads are only the tip of the iceberg, as the ad transparency platform hosts more than two billion ads of which only a small portion was analysed,” said Roongta. “The high incident of deception within this small sample itself highlights the magnitude of these scams being propagated to the users.”

Google has a commercial reason to weed out scams. Software firms have little use for an audience that’s learnt to ignore every advert. Google’s shareholders also have an interest in keeping down the cost of checking the ads. Google pays for the time its own staff spend investigating a fake virus warning. When a worker stops what they’re doing to find out whether their computer really is infected, Google doesn’t pay for a minute of their time. The profit motive driving Google puts its interests in direct contradiction to those of its end user.

The researchers have made AdLens, the tool they built for the study, publicly available. It flags suspicious wording, then examines the text and images in those ads. Consumer groups and regulators can use it to investigate Google’s record for themselves.

One American corporation sold advertisers access to audiences across Europe, while the public paid the cost in wasted time and expense.

Share post

The Team